GTA 6 and Ocarina of Time, United by a Review War

Nov 22, 2026 6 min

User scores for GTA 6 and Ocarina of Time are falling on Metacritic amid accusations from both sides, while critics’ scores remain unchanged.

Ocarina of Time has dropped from 9.6 to 8.6 in its Metacritic user score after receiving zero-point reviews that appear to be a response to the review bombing against GTA 6. Some Rockstar players accuse Nintendo fans of starting the campaign; other users argue the opposite, and it is unclear who posted the coordinated ratings first.

The dispute pits Grand Theft Auto 6 and The Legend of Zelda: Ocarina of Time Remake against each other, two releases caught up in a fan feud. Reviews mentioning the other game and extreme scores have brought the rivalry to Metacritic’s pages, although complaints about GTA 6 are not all the same and do not necessarily stem from the same campaign.

From GTA 6 to reviews targeting Zelda

Hobby Consolas describes low ratings for the Zelda remake as retaliation by users who believe Nintendo players organized the initial attack on GTA 6. One message posted on Ocarina’s page reads “Take your own medicine”. Other comments directly compare the two games and justify the negative score by pointing to the reviews Rockstar’s title received.

Take your own medicine.

— User review on Metacritic

Hobby Consolas also cites a review comparing the €80 price of both games: it criticizes Ocarina as a remake of an old game with better graphics, while arguing that GTA 6 offers a new map, mechanics, and features. The comment ends by warning that those who give GTA 6 zeroes should expect the same treatment. These are user arguments, not a confirmed explanation of how the campaigns began.

Zelda’s figures do not match exactly across the outlets that checked Metacritic. Hobby Consolas and GGRecon recorded an 8.6 on November 22; Notebookcheck reported an 8.7, while Dexerto cited a 9.0. GGRecon specified that its check showed 38,369 ratings, 13% of them negative, and that the critics’ score remained at 95.

GTA 6’s figures also depend on when and where they are checked. Eurogamer and GGRecon put its user score at 5.6, but Dexerto reported a 5.0 for the PlayStation 5 version. GGRecon’s tally, published on November 22, showed 79,218 ratings; Eurogamer cited more than 54,000. In all those reports, Metacritic’s professional rating was 99.

Game or platformUser scoreFigure and stated date
GTA 65.6Eurogamer and GGRecon; GGRecon recorded 79,218 ratings on November 22.
GTA 6 on PS55.0Figure published by Dexerto on November 21.
Ocarina of Time Remake8.6Hobby Consolas and GGRecon, on November 22; GGRecon counted 38,369 ratings.
Ocarina of Time Remake8.7 / 9.0Notebookcheck reported 8.7 and Dexerto 9.0.
Grand Theft Auto VI: An Extended Look — Rockstar Games

Two games with very high critics’ scores

The gap between users and critics is especially pronounced for GTA 6. Metacritic gives it a Metascore of 99, a score that, according to Dexerto and Notebookcheck, ties with the original 1998 Ocarina of Time for the highest in the site’s history. Eurogamer reports that 44% of the more than 54,000 user reviews it checked were negative and that Metacritic classifies its 5.6 as “mixed or average”.

The Zelda remake also started with an exceptionally high user rating: Dexerto put its score at 9.6 on November 8, while GGRecon explained that it had been the highest-rated game of 2026 before GTA 6 arrived. The remake’s professional critics’ score remained at 95 in GGRecon’s tally, despite the drop in its user score.

The two titles also share a connection in their critics’ scores: GTA 6’s 99 matches the Nintendo 64 Zelda. The new version of Ocarina of Time arrived on Nintendo Switch 2 on November 5, according to Dexerto. Metacritic opened community ratings on November 6, according to Notebookcheck, which says the score remained stable until a wave of zeroes arrived in less than 24 hours.

GGRecon adds that the remake sold 5.2 million copies in four days. The review dispute has therefore hit a game that had previously received a strong reception from both users and critics, although that sales figure does not explain who posted the negative ratings.

Genuine criticism and retaliatory reviews

Not every low score for GTA 6 is part of the feud. Eurogamer cites complaints about the 30-frames-per-second cap on consoles and the emphasis on Jason and Lucia’s relationship compared with the criminal activities in previous installments. Dexerto also mentions performance drops, open-world bugs, and objections to the optional romance system.

Other comments criticize the tone and script, or say the game is too realistic and limits player freedom. Eurogamer also notes that some users complain about supposed “woke” agendas and diversity. These are different reasons: a campaign of zeroes can coexist with negative ratings that describe specific aspects of the experience.

Some recent Ocarina messages do not even focus on the game. Several reviews refer directly to GTA 6 or Zelda fans; one cited by Dexerto mocks Nintendo fans, while another accuses users of review-bombing Rockstar’s game. This mix of back-and-forth comments fuels mutual accusations, but cannot by itself establish who started it.

Dexerto observed that some accounts giving GTA 6 zeroes had barely rated any other games, and that the Ocarina remake was the only other title scored on their profiles, with a 10. That pattern may draw attention, but it does not prove that those accounts belong to a particular group or show who coordinated the reviews.

Metacritic does not ask users to prove they own the game

You do not need to prove your purchase to vote on Metacritic, according to Dexerto and GGRecon. This differs from the PlayStation Store, where, according to Dexerto, only people who own the game can rate it. There, GTA 6 had a score of 4.84 out of 5, far above its Metacritic user score.

Notebookcheck notes that all it takes to post a rating on Metacritic is registering an email address. The outlet links this low barrier to the ease of organizing campaigns against a title, although that fact does not identify those responsible for this dispute. GGRecon also warns that there is no clear evidence attributing the negative GTA 6 reviews to Zelda fans.

An analysis cited by Notebookcheck offers another angle, with its own limitations: Reddit user gtrhawk examined 14,000 profiles. According to that tally, 83.8% of those who rated GTA 6 negatively had not rated the Zelda remake. By contrast, 33.5% of negative Ocarina reviews did not also include a rating for GTA 6. Notebookcheck presents these figures as a possible sign of asymmetry, not conclusive proof of who organized the campaigns.

For now, the scores reflect an ongoing review war, not a shared verdict on either game. Critics’ scores remain unchanged in the cited tallies, while user scores continue to vary between checks. The next concrete indicator will be whether new batches of reviews move Metacritic’s figures again, and in which direction.

Sources: Hobby Consolas, Eurogamer.net, Dexerto, Notebookcheck, GGRecon