Nicalis removed music generated with Suno from the GTA 6-inspired secret run in The Binding of Isaac: Repentance+ after players found metadata from the AI tool in the game files and lashed out at the expansion on Steam. Isaac creator Edmund McMillen said he was unaware that generated music had been included.
The controversy erupted around a free update to Repentance+, which brought the content to PS5, Xbox Series X/S, and Switch 2 on November 19, according to Dexerto. The same release added a special daily run on PC with a Vice City aesthetic, promoted as a nod to Grand Theft Auto 6.
To access the run, players had to enter the V1CE BSMT seed before starting. The sequence featured its own weapons and music; the files contained seven full songs and several related snippets, such as intros and outros, according to an analysis published by a Reddit user and reported by Kotaku.
Metadata pointed to Suno
User ShweetsStuff shared an analysis of the music files and noted that some retained metadata comments containing the phrase “made with suno”. One example, associated with the drivingsong1.ogg file, also showed a creation date of October 30, 2026, as well as a file identifier.
Dexerto reported that the player found several tracks with this metadata and links to songs on Suno’s website. Other users later checked the files, according to the outlet. Some tracks no longer retained the comment, which ShweetsStuff’s analysis attributed to their having been edited or exported later.
The run is credited to a modder known as Mr. Headcrab. According to Dexerto, the person who posted the discovery said the modder is opposed to the use of AI and did not know the music had been generated that way. The cited outlets do not attribute any direct statement about the case to the modder.
“Woke up to a shit show, obviously I had no idea it featured generated music in the daily run, looking into how that happened and getting it removed, stay tuned,”
— Edmund McMillen, creator of The Binding of Isaac
McMillen posted that message on X on November 21. Kotaku also reported another post of his asking people to send issues and bugs to an associated email address. His response made clear that he had not known about the generated music and that an investigation was underway into how it ended up in the run.
Backlash against Nicalis and negative reviews
Many players directed their complaints at Nicalis, the expansion’s publisher and co-developer. Kotaku noted that criticism over bugs, latency, and quality control had been building, while Dexerto said some users also blamed the update for breaking mods and causing unexpected crashes.
The reaction had an immediate effect on Steam. Kotaku put the user rating at 9% positive, while Dexerto described recent reviews as “Overwhelmingly Negative” and calculated that 10% of the 908 reviews from the last 30 days were positive. The figures refer to different metrics reported by each outlet.
Among the criticisms, one player summed up their anger by saying the developers had turned to AI even though synthwave was an easy genre to produce. Others called for McMillen to take back control of the game and pointed to the lack of bug fixes in an update they had been waiting more than a year for. The discussion thus combined opposition to the music with earlier complaints about the technical state of the release.
Repentance+’s Steam page did not include a disclosure about the use of AI-generated content. Valve requires developers to indicate on the store page if a game uses assets created with the help of AI, according to both outlets. The absence of that information became another focus of criticism, alongside the decision to include the songs without McMillen’s knowledge.
Patch reaches PC; consoles still pending
In the hours after McMillen’s post, Nicalis distributed a new PC build. Its patch notes listed the removal of the generated music files and also included fixes for mods affected by the launch update, according to Dexerto.
The console versions had not yet received the patch: Nicalis had submitted them to Microsoft, Nintendo, and Sony for approval. The removal was therefore already live on PC, while its arrival on consoles depended on those approvals.
Nicalis had not publicly explained how Suno music ended up in the game or accepted responsibility for its inclusion, according to Kotaku and Dexerto. The company had also not added an AI disclosure to the Steam page. McMillen said he was investigating what happened, but did not specify who added the tracks or when that decision was made.
A GTA 6 nod that was overshadowed
The special run was conceived as a promotional surprise tied to the expansion’s console launch and the release of GTA 6. In recent comments to Eurogamer, McMillen explained that the idea of timing the release with Rockstar’s game came from Nicalis. He described it as a fun experiment and said the team was already ready to release that month.
The nod included the Vice City setting, special weapons, and the soundtrack that sparked the controversy. Rather than remaining a festive addition, the sequence became the focus of criticism when players inspected its files and found references to Suno. The PC patch removed the music, but approval for the PS5, Xbox Series X/S, and Switch 2 versions is still pending.



